Hello,

ser and sip-router flavours are completely the same, just different names for binaries and tools. Historically, being the initial project, ser stays the default flavour

kamailio is different, installing what was traditionally provided by kamailio (openser), one being the database structure specific for kamailio. Then just few things are enabled by default: kamailio's internal statistics and tm module extensions used by seas module.

Then, no matter which flavour you select, all modules are installed, so you can combine them, you need to be sure you create the database table structure specific for what modules you use.

Cheers, Daniel

On 3/23/11 2:57 AM, Claudio Furrer wrote:

Hi Sascha, Thanks your answer.. I'm coming from ser flavour, and need to upgrade to 3.x, then my doubt is specifically related with ser/sip-router. Now I've already have ser binaries (ser, sercmd, etc) and am i asking if new binaries should be named as ser* or siprouter* based on the flavour set.

Moreover, what if it's a new installation and need only common modules and a few of modules_s.. Then which flavour is recommended (ser or sip-router) and which name should the main binaries have.

Again, thank you. Claudio

On Tue, 22 Mar 2011, Sascha Daniels wrote:

...

Hi.

If you use FLAVOUR=kamailio you will get kamailio, kamctl and kamdbctl as binary.

Regards Sascha

Am 22.03.2011 19:42, schrieb Claudio Furrer:

...

Hello,

What is (or should be) the binary main name when using FLAVOUR=ser, FLAVOUR=sip-router or no FLAVOUR specified?

I'm getting "ser" as the name whatever I set to FLAVOUR var at compile time. Is it right? (Makefiles.defs says "ser" in these cases but not sure the intention of the sip-router project).

I need to know the correct one to make an ebuild package for Gentoo. Thank you for your answers..

-- AMOOMA GmbH - Bachstr. 124 - 56566 Neuwied --> http://www.amooma.de Geschäftsführer: Stefan Wintermeyer, Handelsregister Montabaur B14998

Bücher: http://das-asterisk-buch.de - http://ruby-auf-schienen.de

---

SIP Express Router (SER) and Kamailio (OpenSER) - sr-users mailing list sr-users@lists.sip-router.org http://lists.sip-router.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sr-users

Hello,

On 3/23/11 2:33 PM, Claudio Furrer wrote:

...

Hello,

ser and sip-router flavours are completely the same, just different names for binaries and tools. Historically, being the initial project, ser stays the default flavour

I can't get different names for binaries and tools, ser flavour or sip-router flavour give me always "sbin/ser" "sbin/sercmd" etc...

 $ make prefix=/ group_include="standard mysql" \
        include_modules=avpops \
        exclude_modules="rtpproxy nathelper ratelimit mediaproxy" \
        mode=debug all

 $ make prefix=/ BASEDIR=/tmp/sip-router install

Also tried the same but adding FLAVOUR=ser or FLAVOUR=sip-router. Same results.

ok, I will try to look at it, maybe some other variables have to be set there, I am using only the kamailio flavor.

The sercmd is always with this name, even for kamailio flavour, since it is kind of separate application. What changes are the ctl tools, like kamctl or serctl.

Only by modifying the Makefile.defs, the flavour variable get a binary name different. Flavour=ser give me ser* names, flavour=sip-router or no one specified gives siprouter* names, then flavour=kamailio gives kam* names.

I know it's a mess (with myself) but I have a concept misundertanding. I interpret sip-router project has 2 names, kamailio and ser, but not its own name (sip-router). Then it's a matter of packaging issue which i have.

Indeed, you are rigth, there are two application built out of the source tree: - ser - kamailio

To be able to switch between them, 'sip-router' might be used as placeholder in some case, but there is no sip-router application built out of it, of course, unless you want it to be so. The flavour build option is intended to make easy the creation of binaries and configs with different names without changing anything inside the files. Since I am using kamailio and that works fine, maybe ser/sip-router is a bit mixed. I will have a look in the next days.

Thanks, Daniel

...

Then, no matter which flavour you select, all modules are installed, so you can combine them, you need to be sure you create the database table structure specific for what modules you use.

Ok, i understand about modules and db. It's clear.

Thank you Daniel.

-- Claudio