Hello,
I had posted this question earlier on asterisk-users, but didn't receive any reply, so I'm posting on sr-users in the hope that someone can provide guidance on how to debug this problem.
Our setup involves a Sip softphone registering with a fresh install of Asterisk v1.6.0.5 through an outbound proxy (Kamailio v3.1.1).
We observe that about 80% of the time, immediately after startup of the softphone, when the softphone sends a REGISTER message, Asterisk replies with a "503 Server error". However, subsequent REGISTER messages are replied to appropriately (with a 401 Unauthorized).
There are very few devices (under 5) registered with Asterisk, so this is not an overload issue.
Please find attached a SIP trace for device registration.
- What might cause this behavior in Asterisk ? - Are there any config file parameters that require to be changed ? - Would it help to see any other specific logs, if so which ones ?
Thanks and Regards, Vikram.
Hello,
On 12/16/10 6:32 PM, Vikram Ragukumar wrote:
Hello,
I had posted this question earlier on asterisk-users, but didn't receive any reply, so I'm posting on sr-users in the hope that someone can provide guidance on how to debug this problem.
Our setup involves a Sip softphone registering with a fresh install of Asterisk v1.6.0.5 through an outbound proxy (Kamailio v3.1.1).
We observe that about 80% of the time, immediately after startup of the softphone, when the softphone sends a REGISTER message, Asterisk replies with a "503 Server error". However, subsequent REGISTER messages are replied to appropriately (with a 401 Unauthorized).
There are very few devices (under 5) registered with Asterisk, so this is not an overload issue.
Please find attached a SIP trace for device registration.
- What might cause this behavior in Asterisk ?
- Are there any config file parameters that require to be changed ?
- Would it help to see any other specific logs, if so which ones ?
you should set sip debug on for asterisk in order to get more verbose output related to the 503 case. I couldn't spot something wrong for register that got 503. Next ones have two contact headers, but that is fine in SIP.
Cheers, Daniel
Daniel,
you should set sip debug on for asterisk in order to get more verbose output related to the 503 case. I couldn't spot something wrong for register that got 503. Next ones have two contact headers, but that is fine in SIP.
Thanks for your suggestion, I'm working on this and will get back to the list with my findings.
Regards, Vikram.
Daniel,
I had posted this question earlier on asterisk-users, but didn't receive any reply, so I'm posting on sr-users in the hope that someone can provide guidance on how to debug this problem.
Our setup involves a Sip softphone registering with a fresh install of Asterisk v1.6.0.5 through an outbound proxy (Kamailio v3.1.1).
We observe that about 80% of the time, immediately after startup of the softphone, when the softphone sends a REGISTER message, Asterisk replies with a "500 Server error". However, subsequent REGISTER messages are replied to appropriately (with a 401 Unauthorized).
you should set sip debug on for asterisk in order to get more verbose output related to the 503 case. I couldn't spot something wrong for register that got 503. Next ones have two contact headers, but that is fine in SIP.
Cheers, Daniel
I have recently had the chance to do some more debug and here is more information. It appears that the 500 Server Error is generated by Asterisk as a response to an offending REGISTER request from the softphone that has an invalid CSeq number. I have attached an excerpt of a sip trace that shows these messages. The offending REGISTER message has a CSeq that is lower than that of the earlier REGISTER message with the same Call-ID.
My questions are
1) Is the response from Asterisk (500 Server Error) valid ? Wouldn't a 4xx Client Failure response be more appropriate ?
2)The source of this error would probably be a bug in the SIP stack of the soft phone (PJSIP), correct ?
Thanks and Regards, Vikram.
-
Daniel-Constantin Mierla -
Vikram Ragukumar