31 Jan
2006
31 Jan
'06
3:16 a.m.
Hi!
I've read about the above topic in the arcives and now I've got the same
problem.
User A is behind a symmetric NAT -> a new port is bound for every
different
(external ip, external port) pair.
User B has a connection to the net without any NAT or firewall.
User A wants to have a SIP+RTP session with user B. How?
I guess basically what is needed is forming of a SIP
message like "send the your reply to the same ip and
same port from where you have received this" and user
A can send this to user B.
For the RTP session, a pretty similar thing would be
needed like, A says to B: "I send you the RTP stream
on your x port, send your rtp stream back to the same
ip and port from where you receive mine".
How to setup such a SIP packet?
Or maybe there is a standard solution for this already?
(STUN wont help in this case I guess, and TURN is not
an option for me.)
I've read about "symmetric SIP + symmetric RTP" maybe
that is the same as I've described above?
Thanks
Istvan
31 Jan
31 Jan
10:21 a.m.
Use SER nathelper module and rtpproxy.
Use SIP ping from SER every few seconds (not too sparse, because NAT
will close; but not too frequent either - use 8 seconds).
If your device is capable of it - use SIP ping and RTP/RTCP ping every 8
seconds.
--
Regards,
Arek Bekiersz
Istvan De wrote:
Hi!
I've read about the above topic in the arcives and now I've got the same
problem.
User A is behind a symmetric NAT -> a new port is bound for every
different
(external ip, external port) pair.
User B has a connection to the net without any NAT or firewall.
User A wants to have a SIP+RTP session with user B. How?
I guess basically what is needed is forming of a SIP
message like "send the your reply to the same ip and
same port from where you have received this" and user
A can send this to user B.
For the RTP session, a pretty similar thing would be
needed like, A says to B: "I send you the RTP stream
on your x port, send your rtp stream back to the same
ip and port from where you receive mine".
How to setup such a SIP packet?
Or maybe there is a standard solution for this already?
(STUN wont help in this case I guess, and TURN is not
an option for me.)
I've read about "symmetric SIP + symmetric RTP" maybe
that is the same as I've described above?
1 Feb
1 Feb
3:30 a.m.
You are right. The UA of user B needs to support symmetric RTP. Their is also
an extension for SDP called co-media which allows you to explicitly tell the
other side "I will start the media stream" or "you should start the media
stream". But I think it is not a standard yet, and not too much vendors
implemented the draft yet.
Nils
On Tuesday 31 January 2006 03:16, Istvan De wrote:
Hi!
I've read about the above topic in the arcives and now I've got the same
problem.
User A is behind a symmetric NAT -> a new port is bound for every
different
(external ip, external port) pair.
User B has a connection to the net without any NAT or firewall.
User A wants to have a SIP+RTP session with user B. How?
I guess basically what is needed is forming of a SIP
message like "send the your reply to the same ip and
same port from where you have received this" and user
A can send this to user B.
For the RTP session, a pretty similar thing would be
needed like, A says to B: "I send you the RTP stream
on your x port, send your rtp stream back to the same
ip and port from where you receive mine".
How to setup such a SIP packet?
Or maybe there is a standard solution for this already?
(STUN wont help in this case I guess, and TURN is not
an option for me.)
I've read about "symmetric SIP + symmetric RTP" maybe
that is the same as I've described above?
Thanks
Istvan
_______________________________________________
Serusers mailing list
serusers(a)lists.iptel.org
http://lists.iptel.org/mailman/listinfo/serusers
6684
days inactive
6685
days old
2 comments
3 participants
participants (3)
-
Arek Bekiersz -
Istvan De -
Nils Ohlmeier