Hi there,
I'm not totally sure if this is a problem with SER or not, but I have a interesting problem when using uac_replace_from together with LinkSys PAP2 ATAs (and possibly other linksys equipment, retesting tonight.)
When you configure a name in the linksys ATA, you can put your name, ie, for myself I put Patrick Jordan-Smith.
The linksys sends this like:
From: Patrick Jordan-Smith sip:728728@sip.qsi.net.nz
When I try to use uac_replace_from with this from address it chokes on it:
ERROR: parse_to : unexpected char ["] in status 8: <<Beetlestone >> . ERROR:parse_from_header: bad from header ERROR:uac:restore_from_reply: failed to find/parse FROM hdr ERROR: parse_to : unexpected char ["] in status 8: <<Beetlestone >> . ERROR:parse_from_header: bad from header
And I end up with a wrecked From address then nothing works.
I have checked RFC 3261 and it only says quote marks should be used if the field contains a comma, question-mark or semi-colon. So it seems Linksys are following spec and SER is in error.
Any comments on this?
Thanks, Pat
Hi,
has anybody got the Modules "acc" and "auth_diameter" working with opendiameter and, if yes, how?
Thanks, Christoph
Hi Christoph,
the implementation is quite old and there is no guarantee that it will actually work.... the draft become RFC (about SIP and Diameter) and thinks changed....
the review of the DIAMETER part is really required..
regards, bogdan
Christoph Egger wrote:
Hi,
has anybody got the Modules "acc" and "auth_diameter" working with opendiameter and, if yes, how?
Thanks, Christoph
Users mailing list Users@openser.org http://openser.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
Hi Bogdan,
the implementation is quite old and there is no guarantee that it will actually work.... the draft become RFC (about SIP and Diameter) and thinks changed....
When you say old, do you mean the OpenSER modules or DISC (or both of them ;)?
the review of the DIAMETER part is really required..
Is there something planned or some ongoing work in this area? Or is there someone deploying the two OpenSER diameter modules who can comment on problems/changes and/or incompatibilities?
Many thanks regards, --Joachim
Christoph Egger wrote:
Hi,
has anybody got the Modules "acc" and "auth_diameter" working with opendiameter and, if yes, how?
Thanks, Christoph
Users mailing list Users@openser.org http://openser.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
Users mailing list Users@openser.org http://openser.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
Hi Joachim,
Joachim Fabini wrote:
Hi Bogdan,
the implementation is quite old and there is no guarantee that it will actually work.... the draft become RFC (about SIP and Diameter) and thinks changed....
When you say old, do you mean the OpenSER modules or DISC (or both of them ;)?
I mean of openser modules - as there was no diameter library, a protocol was build to communicate with DISC (as entry point in the diameter network).
AFAIK there are changes in the specs regarding diameter and SIP and also I would like to use a diameter library and to follow same approach as for radius.
the review of the DIAMETER part is really required..
Is there something planned or some ongoing work in this area?
the first step (and critical) will be to see if there are any open diameter libs with devel support (maybe in opendiameter project..? )
regards, bogdan
Or is there someone deploying the two OpenSER diameter modules who can comment on problems/changes and/or incompatibilities?
Many thanks regards, --Joachim
Christoph Egger wrote:
Hi,
has anybody got the Modules "acc" and "auth_diameter" working with opendiameter and, if yes, how?
Thanks, Christoph
Users mailing list Users@openser.org http://openser.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
Users mailing list Users@openser.org http://openser.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
Hi Patrick,
can you please post the request (as received on net) that cause the described errors? will be quite usefull...
regards, bogdan
Patrick Jordan-Smith wrote:
Hi there,
I'm not totally sure if this is a problem with SER or not, but I have a interesting problem when using uac_replace_from together with LinkSys PAP2 ATAs (and possibly other linksys equipment, retesting tonight.)
When you configure a name in the linksys ATA, you can put your name, ie, for myself I put Patrick Jordan-Smith.
The linksys sends this like:
From: Patrick Jordan-Smith sip:728728@sip.qsi.net.nz
When I try to use uac_replace_from with this from address it chokes on it:
ERROR: parse_to : unexpected char ["] in status 8: <<Beetlestone >> . ERROR:parse_from_header: bad from header ERROR:uac:restore_from_reply: failed to find/parse FROM hdr ERROR: parse_to : unexpected char ["] in status 8: <<Beetlestone >> . ERROR:parse_from_header: bad from header
And I end up with a wrecked From address then nothing works.
I have checked RFC 3261 and it only says quote marks should be used if the field contains a comma, question-mark or semi-colon. So it seems Linksys are following spec and SER is in error.
Any comments on this?
Thanks, Pat
-
Bogdan-Andrei Iancu -
Christoph Egger -
Joachim Fabini -
Patrick Jordan-Smith