i quote from your email:

Asterisk: registrar with public ip port=5050 open(ser): outbound proxy with public ip port=5060

LOOKS LIKE THE SAME DAMN PORT TO ME.

i tried to help you, i offered to help, but evidently you're more interested in being an ass than getting an answer to your question.

here's one more person who might have helped you who you've pissed off and now won't even bother.

-yair

p.s. dont bother responding, you're on my blacklist.

On 11/23/05, harry gaillac gaillacharry@yahoo.fr wrote:

...

what about this is not clear?

NO ONE CAN HELP YOU

maybe it's because your problem is esoteric maybe it's because you're not explaining it well maybe it's because you continue to attempt to use idioms in english when it's clear that you have no understanding of them maybe it's because you frequently come across as threatening (as in "when i get an answer i'll stop posting") maybe it's because you cross-post

it's up to you to make clear what you are looking for, and then to ASK FOR (as opposed to demanding) help.

You're kidding I spend time to explain my problem

...

i, for one, use SER and asterisk together, SER as the SIP proxy and Asterisk as the dialplan server and PSTN gateway. I get SER to do the NAT transversal using mediaproxy and nathelper, and use the dialplan and gateway features in asterisk because of increased call control, cleaner dialplan logic, call logging, all that good stuff. If i understand you correctly, you want to use asterisk as a proxy (why, i don't know, it's not a great SIP proxy). If i can help, i will, but i have to first understand what you want to do.

Thanks but I've ever done

...

for example, you claim to be running both asterisk and SER on the same box on the same port. unless i'm missing something with the NAT/public IP setup, that seems like a not such-a-good-idea.

Not the same port

...

and stop sending diagrams. they only make it worse.

...

and, here is the golden rule, and you yourself say this: if you send a question and dont get an answer, DO NOT SEND THE SAME QUESTION AGAIN, because, surprisingly enough, you won't get an answer and you will piss people off.

Here is an other golden rule when you can help do it

Regards Harry

---

Appel audio GRATUIT partout dans le monde avec le nouveau Yahoo! Messenger Téléchargez cette version sur http://fr.messenger.yahoo.com