On 01.10.2009 13:56 Uhr, Olle E. Johansson wrote:
[...]
SNMPstats currently lives in modules_k. As we've got an OID for Kamailio.org it's time to update the module.
- Change the OID - maybe with a config option if people depend on
the old
- Change file names on all files starting with "openser". I don't
see why we need a name tag in these file names. Anyone else? openserObjects.h could very well be snmpObjects.h
- Update all MIBS so that we don't use the openser namespace or
OID. I would suggest that we change all "openser" tags to "siprouter" to enable this module to move in to core at some point. Changing MIBs to have "kamailio" in all names doesn't seem very long term for me.
Maybe we should consider using the common SIP mib for where we follow it and only use Kamailio/Sip-router specific mibs for extras. I think our MIBS was created at a very early stage of the SIP mibs. Anyone that knows more about this and have comments?
Looking from my newbie perspective I don't see any reason on why we should in large parts copy the standard MIB and still use our own definitions.
Daniel, Thanks for the commits. I think you failed to read the part where I said "I can start working on this" ;-)
I did miss it. Send me the ssh key so you can apply changes. I am more that happy if you can take over this work.
I still want to have a discussion about the last part above - why are we not using the standard SIP mib where we can?
Well, I think we should use the standard SIP mibs where they are available.
Also, maybe we should reorganize the mib so that we suballocate for future use outside of snmp
kamailiooid.10 SNMP kamailiooid.20 LDAPRight now I believe we're using the full OID directly for snmp subclasses.
Anyone that has experience of organizing OID trees that can give some input?
We can't change it in every release, as we will propably break existing scripts and management platforms, so we will have to try to do it right while we're messing with it :-)
OK, but since I haven't been using it heavily, I cannot say how is better to have the OID trees. Therefore I can help a bit more with messing that with doing it right from first time :-) .
Cheers, Daniel