Re: [sr-dev] kamctl and sercmd unification proposal

Hello, As kamailio and ser get more and more unified, sharing common modules and core, one of the last remaining points is the intermixed usage of kamctl and sercmd to setup specific parameters. One example is the cfg framework changes (from ser) that Kamailio 3.1.0 will bring, that will require the use of "sercmd" on setting specific module config params. The issue is that the documentation also references the "kamctl" utility to specify reload actions etc. What I suggest is that we strip kamctl with its fifo capabilities and leave it only with DB, ACL management and such(that sercmd doesn't provide), and use only sercmd on examples in the documentation files. This will require no changes to code (well some features from kamctl will be deprecated), but only documentation changes. This will ensure that documentation is kept well organized and coherent across modules. These are the modules required to use sercmd (based on functionality), the 4th case being the one that I am mostly interested (offers full access to Kamailio commands) 1. basic (required for every case - basic ser commands) : modules/ctl/ctl.so 2. configuration framework change : modules/cfg_rpc/cfg_rpc.so 3. fifo comands (kamctl fifo) : modules/mi_rpc/mi_rpc.so (does not require modules_k/mi_fifo/mi_fifo.so) In this case no kamailio core commands are available (like kamctl debug, kamctl uptime, kamctl which) Because readline is based on the which command (lists all available commands), no tab completion is available 4. all K commands : along with mi_rpc, module_k/kex/kex.so is required. In this case sercmd has tab completion (because core commands like which are available) Of course the removal of kamctl fifo commands will mean that module_k/mi_fifo/mi_fifo.so module will not be required anymore(But I strongly suggest that we keep it to allow backwards compatibility) Suggestions?! Cheers Marius _______________________________________________ sr-dev mailing list sr-dev(a)lists.sip-router.org http://lists.sip-router.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sr-dev