[Devel] RADIUS Dictionary

[Peter Nixon]

On Tue 14 Nov 2006 01:02, you wrote:
> Peter Nixon wrote:
> > Why is it that neither SER nor OpenSer has submitted the SER radius
> > dictionary for inclusion in FreeRADIUS??? I notice all the documentation
> > explains how to copy it in, but the correct solution would be to have it
> > as a vendor dictionary and be done with it. Does anyone have anything
> > against me committing it to FreeRADIUS cvs? I also notice that it doesn't
> > currently have a vendor number from IANA at the top (has everyone just
> > been too lazy to apply for one?). The author of the radius module should
> > apply for one, or alternatively we can just use mine (26514)
> >
> > We have a new stable FreeRADIUS release due out in the near future (days
> > or weeks at most) so a quick decision will allow for inclusion in what
> > should be the final release of the 1.1x branch.
> >
> > Waiting for replies/flames before I do anything...
>
> I think this is a great idea that will reduce a lot of installation
> hassles.

Can anyone tell me why the Sip-Method Values in the dictionary with OpenSER:

### Sip-Method Values ###
VALUE Sip-Method         Undefined      0
VALUE Sip-Method         Invite         1
VALUE Sip-Method         Cancel         2
VALUE Sip-Method         Ack            4
VALUE Sip-Method         Bye            8
VALUE Sip-Method         Info           16
VALUE Sip-Method         Options        32
VALUE Sip-Method         Update         64
VALUE Sip-Method         Register       128
VALUE Sip-Method         Message        256
VALUE Sip-Method         Subscribe      512
VALUE Sip-Method         Notify         1024
VALUE Sip-Method         Prack          2048
VALUE Sip-Method         Refer          4096
VALUE Sip-Method         Other          8192

Dont match the values in draft-schulzrinne-sipping-radius-accounting-00.txt:

             0  INVITE
             1  BYE
             2  REGISTER
             3  CANCEL
             4  OPTIONS
             5  ACK
             6  SUBSCRIBE
             7  NOTIFY

Not only does OpenSER have more values, but the integers dont match the same 
values in the spec....

-- 

Peter Nixon
http://www.peternixon.net/
PGP Key: http://www.peternixon.net/public.asc