[Users] dialog module configuration question
Michel Bensoussan
michel at extricom.com
Tue Feb 27 07:53:00 CET 2007
Hi
"I think the best approach is to force the UAC vendors to align to the
SIP specifications."
Well..... Good luck.
I don't know why but I think if I call and tell them "get back all you
products and upgrade them to align to the SIP specification" they won't
listen to me. But may be I'm wrong.
Any way. I have to deal with it. Do you have some suggestions? What is
the best dialog module version to start with?
I'm not familiar with SIP but I understand that the "To" header won't
change during a session. Is that right? I'm not sure the "CallID" will
be them same in case of re-INVITE.
So I can save the "To" header in the dialog table and check it if the
rm_param is not found.
I'm not sure how to do this.
Andy, If you have some suggestions too...
Regards,
Michel.
Bogdan-Andrei Iancu wrote:
> Hi Michael,
>
> as you give you the same answer as to Andy :) :
>
> "To be honest I'm not fan of complicating my life just to support
> broken stuff :)....doing dialog matching in traditional way (without
> using RR stuff) is very costly and since complete, un-altered RR
> mirroring is mandatory by RFC3261, I see no point of doing it
> different. "
>
> I think the best approach is to force the UAC vendors to align to the
> SIP specifications.
> regards,
> bogdan
>
>
> Michel Bensoussan wrote:
>> Hi Bogdan
>> I'm agree with you, but we cannot control the UAS devices so we have
>> to handle the case it doesn't correctly mirror the RR header. Can we
>> base the dialog states on From and To headers? or Callid? I
>> understand the the rr_param is used for fast dialog matching (dialog
>> README). Checking dialog matching with headers (From, To, ...),
>> will consequently slowing the transaction?
>>
>> Regards,
>> Michel.
>>
>> Bogdan-Andrei Iancu wrote:
>>> Hi Michel,
>>>
>>> looking at the net capture, it seams that the UAS device
>>> (User-Agent: WLAN660-S VoIP PHONE) does not correctly mirror the RR
>>> header - it is removing the hdr parameters, mirroring only the URI,
>>> which is bogus.
>>>
>>> regards,
>>> bogdan
>
>
>
More information about the Users
mailing list