[SR-Users] home pbx server experience

[u]

Should UAC work with Sipgate and freevoipdeal (dellmont)?

Thanks for your answers everyone.

2013/5/15 u <ueberwachungsstaat at googlemail.com>:
> Should UAC work with Sipgate and freevoipdeal (dellmont)?
>
> Thanks for your answers everyone.
>
> 2013/5/15 Stefan Sayer <stefan.sayer at googlemail.com>:
>>
>> if you don't get it all (auth + registrations) working with kamailo,
>> you might try sems (iptel.org/sems) with sbc module (auth of outgoing
>> calls) and for registrations either reg_agent (cfg file)  or
>> db_reg_agent (accounts from db) modules.
>>
>> load_plugins=uac_auth;registrar_client;reg_agent;sbc;xmlrpc2di
>> application=sbc
>>
>>
>> http://ftp.iptel.org/pub/sems/doc/current/ModuleDoc_sbc.html
>> http://ftp.iptel.org/pub/sems/doc/current/ModuleDoc_reg_agent.html
>> http://ftp.iptel.org/pub/sems/doc/current/AppDoc.html
>>
>> BR
>> Stefan
>>
>> o Edson - Lists on 05/15/2013 06:40 AM:
>>> Hi...
>>>
>>> Use UAC module to manage registrations and play a little with the
>>> config (INVITE section) to forward output calls correctly.
>>> ---
>>> Edson.
>>>
>>> Em 14/05/2013 11:27, u escreveu:
>>>> I would like to share my experience with kamailio and other home pbx
>>>> servers.
>>>>
>>>> Kamailio on my kirkwood home router for my 6 SIP users is perhaps
>>>> overkill: I don't really need mysql and "scalability". But at last I
>>>> finally managed to make calling between registered users work stable.
>>>> My voip clients only work in all NAT scenarios if I work around some
>>>> bugs: to use csipsimple on android I had to change rtpproxy_manage()
>>>> to rtpproxy_manage("c") in kamailio's default config, so that problems
>>>> with conflicting c: entries in the SDP go away.
>>>>
>>>> I propose kamailio could ship with a special example
>>>> kamailio-compatible.cfg that doesn't try to be RFC compliant, but
>>>> compatible to the most common voip clients. Right now the only thing I
>>>> would change for this is the option for rtpproxy_manage, but I'm sure
>>>> others will know more common quirks that could safely be enabled to
>>>> increase compatibility. I think this compatibility idea is what yate
>>>> sticks to for their defaults. In freeswitch you also have to do it all
>>>> manually, and it's much more work to figure things out in their
>>>> enormous config files.
>>>>
>>>> The other SIP proxies I had tried before kamailio officially fit all
>>>> my requirements, including support for multihomed dynamic IPs, but
>>>> contrary to their claims it didn't work.
>>>> Yate was easy to set up, but the default dialplan is more confusing
>>>> than powerful and after having made everything work I realised yate
>>>> was clogging my CPU and RAM and after some time always randomly
>>>> stopped working. This is with only 2 users connected! It also wasn't
>>>> possible to fix NAT sdp while leaving the codecs section in the SDP
>>>> alone at the same time. I tried to debug the code, but the C++ was so
>>>> complex that I had to give up.
>>>> Freeswitch was much more difficult to setup, a multihomed setup with
>>>> dynamic IP was super buggy and it also didn't help that the
>>>> unintuitive configuration is all in complex unreadable XML
>>>> configuration files.
>>>>
>>>> Kamailio and rtpproxy don't officially support dynamic IP address, but
>>>> I can just restart both each time my DSL provider forces me to a new
>>>> IP address. This happens automatically in the night and is no big
>>>> hassle really. The most simple, least-featureful solution works best
>>>> it seems.
>>>>
>>>> Now the last problem I have with kamailio: I don't know how to connect
>>>> my accounts to my sip providers (i.e. Sipgate, Betamax, Dellmont).
>>>> I would like a simple way to do this, preferably without other
>>>> features that always seem to complicate the matters. Is there
>>>> something more lightweight and simple than asterisk, freeswitch and
>>>> yate, that people use successfully for this task together with
>>>> kamailio and rtpproxy?
>>>>
>>>> u
>>>>
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> SIP Express Router (SER) and Kamailio (OpenSER) - sr-users mailing list
>>>> sr-users at lists.sip-router.org
>>>> http://lists.sip-router.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sr-users
>>>> .
>>>>
>>>
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> SIP Express Router (SER) and Kamailio (OpenSER) - sr-users mailing list
>>> sr-users at lists.sip-router.org
>>> http://lists.sip-router.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sr-users
>>>
>>