[Users] open letter

[Iqbal]

okay, so ALL your users are registering to asterisk...is that correct.

If so the problem is howto accept users from behind a NAT into asterisk, 
or am I confusing things further.

If the above are true, where is SER in this, or are users hitting SER 
and you are sending the REGISTER from ser into asterisk.

Iqbal

harry gaillac wrote:

>  
>
>>Let me get this straight
>>
>>All you are doing is registering the devices with
>>SER (below you have 
>>mentioned asterisk, and then you say they goto ser)
>>    
>>
>
>No to asterisk.
>Asterisk  should handle INVITE, REGISTER via ser.
>SER should handle IM/presence
>
>  
>
>>Once they are registered to ser you wish to send
>>them to asterisk...is 
>>this correct
>>
>>If so, this does not seem to hard, NAT ius dealt
>>with in ser, I use 
>>mediaproxy, others may use nathelper, so before you
>>send to asterisk 
>>take care of NAT issues in SER and then send to
>>asterisk.
>>
>>Paste config, in pastebin, and also a ngrep of the
>>call debug.
>>
>>Iqbal
>>
>>harry gaillac wrote:
>>
>>    
>>
>>>Hello open(ser) asterisk users
>>>
>>>Here is what i expect to do :
>>>
>>>Asterisk: registrar with public ip port=5050
>>>open(ser): outbound proxy with public ip port=5060
>>>
>>>
>>>Asterisk don't support IM and presence so i want to
>>>use SER because of it's a good proxy:
>>>
>>>I want user agents behind nat send registration to
>>>asterisk because of it's an ipbx :-)
>>>
>>>Look at this diagram when user agent behind nat
>>>      
>>>
>>send
>>    
>>
>>>REGISTER to ser 
>>>the contact field in sip header has a private
>>>      
>>>
>>address
>>    
>>
>>>which one is forward to asterisk for registration.
>>>
>>>When user agent are registered in asterisk AOR is
>>>sip:user at private ip so asterisk query 
>>>"sip:user at private" behind nat (not possible).
>>>
>>>How a session between two user agents behind nat
>>>      
>>>
>>could
>>    
>>
>>>keep in the path
>>>
>>>       |register |            | register   | 
>>>      
>>>
>>agent1 
>>    
>>
>>>asterisk|         |ser/nat box |            |
>>>       | 200 OK  |            |    200 OK  | 
>>>      
>>>
>>agent2 
>>    
>>
>>>             One box
>>>    ---------------------------
>>>    |  ----------------       |
>>>    |  | asterisk pbx |       | 
>>>    |  ----------------       |
>>>    |        ||               |
>>>    |  ----------    ----------
>>>    |  |   SER  |====|NAT box |==== private
>>>      
>>>
>>network
>>    
>>
>>>    |  ----------    ----------
>>>    ---------------------------
>>>
>>>Send me your questions if you don't understand what
>>>      
>>>
>>i
>>    
>>
>>>expect to do .
>>>
>>>Harry
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>	
>>>
>>>	
>>>		
>>>      
>>>
>>___________________________________________________________________________
>>
>>    
>>
>>>Appel audio GRATUIT partout dans le monde avec le
>>>      
>>>
>>nouveau Yahoo! Messenger 
>>    
>>
>>>Téléchargez cette version sur
>>>      
>>>
>>http://fr.messenger.yahoo.com
>>    
>>
>>>_______________________________________________
>>>Users mailing list
>>>Users at openser.org
>>>http://openser.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
>>>
>>>
>>>.
>>>
>>> 
>>>
>>>      
>>>
>
>
>
>	
>
>	
>		
>___________________________________________________________________________ 
>Appel audio GRATUIT partout dans le monde avec le nouveau Yahoo! Messenger 
>Téléchargez cette version sur http://fr.messenger.yahoo.com
>
>
>.
>
>  
>