[Serusers] [jcollins at asgardsrealm.net: Routing difference between 0.8.10 and 0.8.12]

[Jamin W. Collins]

I sent the following message to to the serteam address per (Jiri's
request) several days ago regarding an apparent routing difference
between 0.8.10 and 0.8.12.  I've yet to receive any indication that it
was received and/or that anyone is looking into this.  

I'm reposting it here (with configs and traces) in hopes that someone
here can either indicate what I've done wrong or confirm that these two
configurations should work the same.

----- Forwarded message from "Jamin W. Collins" <jcollins at asgardsrealm.net> -----

From: "Jamin W. Collins" <jcollins at asgardsrealm.net>
To: serteam at iptel.org

I believe I've found a routing difference between 0.8.10 and 0.8.12.  I
originally brought this up on the serusers list[1].  Jiri has suggested
that I forward the configurations and ngrep captures to this address,
you should find these attached to this message.  The ngrep capture from
20031204 contains the Snom phone's request against the 0.8.10
configuration.  The 20031205 capture contains a Snom and Cisco request
against the 0.8.12 configuration.  The Snom phone works as expected
against the 0.8.10 configuration, but not he 0.8.12.  The Cisco phone
works as expected against the 0.8.12 configuration.

[1] - http://lists.iptel.org/pipermail/serusers/2003-December/004272.html

----- End forwarded message -----

-- 
Jamin W. Collins

This is the typical unix way of doing things: you string together lots
of very specific tools to accomplish larger tasks. -- Vineet Kumar
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: ser.cfg-0.8.10.gz
Type: application/octet-stream
Size: 842 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://lists.sip-router.org/pipermail/sr-users/attachments/20031217/61b16c7c/attachment-0003.obj>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: ser.cfg-0.8.12.gz
Type: application/octet-stream
Size: 1614 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://lists.sip-router.org/pipermail/sr-users/attachments/20031217/61b16c7c/attachment-0004.obj>
-------------- next part --------------
?G
?? ser-20031204 ??]??8????SP?????@????L2?53?Tw2???a??l????G?????qwR??
?~???#!]}Vt?pK?[?(?????MU?0????????jm??4o??b?R?|x?(w?~?????N??I;}?r????HU????????_>?X?
?1Xs??'??+??????8I????p??????????k????0???/???
8??Q?o????:?{?/_??O)?z??)???{X????????/m;?a"D????=???c????'5u??#???????h?bR????&X{?s;t??bB?
????????Ki??yG?y???	?I??N?
X?????yCU?G<l???1X???j?	?C??{??!?Kb?.
?5??^?o+???*WW?? p???H?*?????1????c?? XKc?S?r
?J?hi?????Dst?R[s(?-?0O?-????D?{?N? ?V???Rz??u?YV?=g<?b?'?????5?.RB?nB?He?????-04}???s9????q??7U??k??!????q?vmg??|8?&???????G?????dB??OC??j????\~??????v?q??5Fw?Q??Itrzf???x|9??????C7Fa%=s,?i??8?1?&t?2z???T?Q5??????j	??????3?i?e?qM???T2???MM????W?#;F??UG|6?h0??9?#?1?X??n\?:.?)\R??????s???????(0??:????e?qMXKC%??9???????????}g?x6?#A ?g??=3x?u?,??????????xPI]?????????????????b?V?8q?????&
????Q?ljRG?k:??xc??1OC?V?8&??:??j???2lB?????)<?L!???d
/??o)??1???~??;#?+x2??3?k???1??g??L???????=?Yp??Jsf????ki?d?1????y???1?]???D{?iRSF???|?????wJ>????w??X_???
??h??'a?N???j?	?`MJMS???
???3????|2R?? 2???Wq???? ?=C?z?i?b?)??p:?V?????$?
Z^>/??;??l?????c???|?8|?????wl-????7??ke????h???e?q?g????3?v???,H#K?.q???r,??/?cI?ZK????X?E?v?7?e????$?{9c(5??2.|>Q??!?q????75.l1??Y?|\???ou$???#?q?oT?'ShY?????q??:ShY?u??C?B?d???Y??%?R~?]%?	???(=#2????????C?v\?&7S??.?K?$V?QqW_??U???s7_#?K?0:B?J?QT?`????nu?<?|?m_u??j??Lu?5?d?l]]?L??h???????j??????."????????'?^?Y???p?uXoj???@7Id??.5y?!}@
4?/?*uUJ?????S?*[:
?????|??Sg???"r?]?_????Plb??o?hQ-??k(p????i|?????A1^?<??
NG??4?}{?????
??Q{ym?p#
drN????x?c<??|???JVu?Qk??Mq?s???x?i?r??q#r????x:rx?Nc?!???5,
??^???d??[?o?D???4?I??u??|?&???uk??????c???m?3?
D??_??"???rs^ks?kg?@e?A?<????7Y???????[?sn??a?;<s[????Y?????gI?}y???[IA??????ay)????
???J#<??X~?=l?6????#???h?r$6?b?HRm???I?M???%?6ER???I?M???5I?)??&?6ER?$??Hj????M???~???I?m?S?"?I?R?c?????D??H)??>?r;??
"????`O??V?j=?VM|2?#?@%??(O???????0?????~z?Jy???W??7???????????w????R???????`?????O?????9~?|?K???????_????????t"???m%?G<|?@k????'C?I???sJq&???=)??? k?=?3`??gz???L2p?5??.8??Q?d????????q?~T(??|:??/????b??`6*??4?1u?]j2[ha??J???t??a?7?QGQH??x???=?fAO?MK?0????X???d?L??-J?r?V1?]??
Qr6-???d?$???X*i???a?$?&??Q?aM{^??????qF??3.P9????I??b?*he?:.????X[pFtz?Z5????qt???%?6-?R??@:?1??	??06?c??=',??	?tOq?}pF????{?t?????>?]?ih6??}:s+D????2=?X[??z?8??-?nK^???MJ???L9??@?@?X:U???h???8#?m??????-Q?i?j?tU??pu??????????f??k?G?X;?<??X? *4db?S?@v8y?j???	b?0r?????/??B~d????????}???}??m?.K2* ?@???@T???<?N?U!???MF?B1/H??"??\/9?N????????|? ??%G?j??h?Y??b?*he?:2??Q?x???2?y????8???????c S???R
?,?:B A??+M??"???n6J????}-??w&?`?7??U	?Hp"??;?6???????\-???^h)?a]??????hb??p?z?,8??Q?? k??-?h?n?{S???????D?D?-8???b??v?????^??`????4???M?s?w?????2?h??t? ?K?X$?z???[K?j?
^Q???t???;H4?Q???~ O!A?r??c??_?0+S,SU?NOF?????3??????O???b?????^4?>l?L????2??U<a??E0?9B????!??Q?Q??n??Y}^Eh????  ???b5??T?4T(|??$p????4?+'">+x?&+'?????u?$b????qs????J????"3?U????z9??
,????Z??I????C7q?k	?r?g???p?G?NK{=???i?Q?}??i?Q?&??!'&j??+??D?|???vb?????D???+????????N??c??X;??J;1?????Nl?t]????r?k
N??L?	R???0??@B????p@R9??6$'X??T?+??y"q?M?"?l`??r?~0??1?K2?kV?zG??N?????_?f?Z	?/[??Lr=??}ui???M??Z????O????  ?j??"??????6Y??!?/???!??????>!?i??F?????#E?1Q?a?-????p?K?????H?o??5
n??iZ??.??D???3?7???3VN?|`?9????a1(P??%?Ih?(Y????Q?T??K???:?????"F?`\?a???`\??j???A?R?6????4?GBX????`???,????Q?E?^d???X?kS?=S;~???????x?m-?l???1?.??^
?J?!??????J	???qH???T???2?<=8^?e?????????L??oY)?L\=R!j]V*?:??XVju^?tY)?F??K?i?T+????O&y?l?>==?_Zs?????????,?A?~YZs?3?LB??O?&
?????????UM??X??]Z?????5?W_Z?A?9Y@?R?9??5??Z???_?EDO?,??????????/????^x??5Q"JA%?,?.65?#u?j[???V?9?#?b?AW??????QDgF??????3L??PGrQ?]??????-}VD?u
*?????????u?J?H?[u,3??????m
6?\??K?/?]??`MvO??#?????b??????'r.?X?IGN???L_?/?mn??f???u????C????0Sn????L??Xv|s{3??o??GX??{9??????)??.5??"????\??bQ^r"d??f?%Ykep<n|s?????k?SM&>?a|s
Q2?4??????IX;
?\???|t???? ??oE???o??0?1?Y??M?G+?nuV??????f??<???n???bj??l
?5??}?|??????y?p???z?1??B??RMI-???a[??70u?%{??.?]??????X>SF??^?z????????????????2
???h? $?{\????hd??????x???>i??T#??,??????8	??
?W?;|?7????S ??D#?GFQ???????7???AL????5?,???!?)?????(??0?_??X???a&j?>??rF?L??TaB?V???R???"?(??<?X????????t??QP???(l?K? _??JL?X?W*1?&? ?Kl??????ed^?=o?????0?"??
??????.???aqF????&???H??'bl5S???a?2????-a?4?-?$6q!??k?E???x]?>?v^4???X??>??%g5a??3k@???g'??h?A?3?W?.?]8???????Sd????*w?a??X???x0??????r????4y
?x?[??k&?z#?;???L1<??Y?????].???????Y.???[???sK?6?ZLN??u[??[?Nl????????md?&?T??d?l?A??<&?#w?L,?\????>v9-?)\T?LCX??g&??1????y????H??B?~?rf?????y?g?)f????f?G?u+??s4??n?????z???t???????[sF?.???c???(?dLA%3C&??f?8???????.3d??!#?5U?bl?,?z??/,??L?ML??G?pv???A?Ng? ?.???3F???n?W??D???3???o]2f^???=R?S??u??????<????|??.Y>v???7??L?QS???????p??-o??o???H???????N????M??	??z;??P??q?iL?q???????=???q{????7?X&???pZ??'m??j??s??P???Z??l??H?????NC?S???
????t2??????
!???5??E?????~4?l=vk?m2???4?I??u??|?&???uk??????c???m?3?
??????????/7??6??v????a???y????'rU???n???y??????m9v?2???<?
m>K?cy???[IA??????1?+6?A?6?}??m???q??FK/?z???MV?d:?c1,,?6ER#R?rjS$5?E??M???2jS$5b*???I
X?T?"?C=rjS$5Bs???HjDfBNm???I?M??$?H??1Jda?#?(?????N]Fqj?????d?G??J??Q??v??g"?%??q??z??:v??\8?~????d(-?4MB?.??K]?3]W?N0!?.???3??? ???g??? 1??3?02?v:?g$?q"??J???*i?f"?%???  ??n?{z?{?~7???=M?????<n?;s???-?}??D?_???
KJ?(???i??\?Q(oy???????&???j?WMh??LFJ?v??E?????????[EWr?+Y9???Vq??D?.W{??Qz????E?Qz???a?E??????uQn??z???q?L?4v?i?M????????
?/???&8$/1?<????
????Z??P???s??i*??Wi*???p?9,~F????????????#?!}@
48?????k,??z??P?????????(?&
????Q?ljRG??F%u?,?{Ju???(?t?u??.???&??????sYoS??????|?_::?c??/<?
RNID	E?0???++???[??(?????Z~??a??????(?<V?'?=?@5??#??#?@h?q?;??O@:j????c,p,N?n??.3o??#??)?+? ?t????=???{????
TS?8??!;2?B-;????????	?&#???NdG\Cp?#???oe?WWl?
;???
g???O.0n???f?!TS?8???7k/R???eG?#]&?9q*?;??:J????=??TL?:?????$?_)???cOT???)v????????b??BvD??#??8?????y??~;??#B
???)????X??pF???v??jVB5??Z?????????b??Bv??n9????????p???y3\????
9???\??p& ??????&
??t????!;?
DZv???????Ck?+????_E??i???xK|^X?yX?????a???|?"??&}~???I????\$??p5w?t?Yw?F8??????????|???|??U?z???l???A?]?jV?p'?g??Y?oW?N?T?f???7gQ??.=Q?jC?&???bc(R?c???E?/Y?3c??G;f?X???6T?P?z?m7??Tjiw?F??n?PV?|??S=C??$A??TX???p??G?$?]$???
??T$?bc???S_??#9!v|`?nV;??k????1M???FE????-$i\'<?Cn?(???
g[????jVB5??#????????q??n!v????R??q((w?HZ?????Ot???<??(?????jG?3????5????6?j?a???!;?@b=;?t?-??dG??q	?t?>$?\???? ???4??U`j?????9?[.???j?? ?)v???????G:?bG?#?v??\8?B?????+y?7oG??4????9????r& ?\???6?j?G?1d?P@?[?F:?bG???-^?@?8??\?ey?hx?3??mX?????V??V;~?a???'?-g@5??#???#?{???????????W????f???

??e????m??G?>	?G? Q?Sy?Y????)?????? x?k??2@?6JX?(tb;?*???0?r?k?/I??^?.?[?T|?T
g??D???6R
???F?1UH4?
????5R??T???Z??G???9?$???X??#?w^?+??Q?vT8k??];?D5?
??b?l??B?B??????????v?e?i??	;n? ?NU??3o?X$eo????(W;~?L4??{????PM??6???G?f?????????#?fX?WD?Wk'???^??????Bo
?5?"+???
v
gr?o?=Q?jC?&?????#i?h?B???o????a)^1d???xC?,?????? )?[???2+o?hm?S8?PX.??j]PMz?V?1dG?I?;???`?@v???_????Y?a?.v1???k??u??)?b???N??@`???'?Ym?;?`c??,?l!A?m?s ;?n??0??g?{?o6????0
0?()????d???N?L??;8v???r6?j?G?1???7
-????????rJ ?;??????'3IK?y??4????N?L??????????z ??"iSg???f??;?c[W?~S??7?_E??i?????FH?^?V
|????????q?S!?6+u?0???J}?/?H?O?j?"i????1B?????w! ?CO?g????5?`yI?D??+W??K???'?Ym???.*6?"U?OzW??+w?HE?#??q7?L/}J??.(X1??_n??_ `
 
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: ser-20031205.gz
Type: application/octet-stream
Size: 4277 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://lists.sip-router.org/pipermail/sr-users/attachments/20031217/61b16c7c/attachment-0005.obj>